Author: Columba John Hawthorne

I'm an amateur philosopher and lay theologian based in Scotland, UK.

Book Review: The Rise and Fall of Rational Control: The History of Modern Political Philosophy

Harvey C. Mansfield’s “The Rise and Fall of Rational Control” analyses modern political philosophy from Machiavelli to Nietzsche. It argues that attempts to govern human affairs through reason often overlook the complexities of human nature and society. Rather than mastering circumstances, political action is characterised by judgement and response to uncertainty.

Book Review: Political Economy from Pufendorf to Marx: Culture, Needs and Property Rights

István Hont’s posthumous collection, “Political Economy from Pufendorf to Marx,” edited by Lasse S. Andersen and others, comprises seven unpublished papers exploring Marxism through the lens of natural jurisprudence. The work examines property rights, human needs, and critiques Marx’s theories by emphasising the persistence of human dependency and political problems within developed commercial societies.

Book Review: The Chile Project and Inside Thatcher’s Monetarism Experiment

Andy Burnham, the new British Prime Minister, has reignited discussions around neoliberalism, linking its failures to the decline of industrial communities. While Sebastián Edwards and Tim Lankester’s works critique past economic models, they reveal that neoliberalism’s legacy remains due to practical adaptations rather than ideological purity, complicating any calls for alternatives.

A Work Beyond Its Proper Limits: Umwelt, Biosemiotics, and the Inheritance of Worlds

The essay explores how organisms bring forth meaning and significance through their evolutionary history and interactions with their environments. It examines the concept of Umwelt, highlighting that inherited capacities shape an organism’s engagement with the world. Evolution results in a continuous history of relations, with organisms altering their surroundings and passing on these changes to future generations.

Film Review: The Odyssey

The Odyssey, directed by Christopher Nolan, captures the essence of Homer’s epic through stunning IMAX cinematography and powerful performances, particularly by Matt Damon and Anne Hathaway. Nolan explores themes of memory, identity, and the dangers of civilisational collapse, while blending past and present in a compelling narrative that honours the source material’s complexity.

No One Here Gets Out Alive: Jim Morrison and the Philosophical Poetics of The Lords and the New Creatures

The essay reflects on Jim Morrison’s artistic vision, intertwining themes of existence, perception, and the dualities of life. It critiques societal structures that commodify experience while advocating for a more profound engagement with reality. Morrison’s call to “reinvent the gods” invites individuals to rethink identity and embrace transformative relationships in a complex world.

The Nature That We Are: A Critique of Marxian Naturalism

Karl Marx’s perspective on human nature presents a complex relationship between humanity and nature, positioning labour as a transformative process. However, his views create a hierarchy that privileges human consciousness over non-human life, raising concerns about alienation and the implications of communism. Ultimately, the analysis suggests a need to rethink the interconnectedness of nature and human evolution beyond Marxian frameworks.

A Just and Loving Gaze: On the Cosmic Task of Art

The essay critiques the notion that beauty is solely subjective, arguing instead that true beauty arises from a disciplined perception that allows subjects to reveal their complexities. Drawing on the philosophies of Heidegger and Murdoch, it asserts that art must strive for a truthful representation of reality, embracing the intricacies and contradictions inherent within.